Tamesis Issue 241 January 2014
There are forms for two events enclosed with this Tamesis. We’ve booked James
Weeks to conduct a workshop on some of Rosenmüller’s music for Vespers on
Saturday 5th April. It’s ten years since TVEMF did this splendid work in a two-day
workshop in Chesham so it’s time we looked at it again. This time we will be in our
excellent new Oxford venue, the Wesley Memorial Church Hall, right in the centre of
the city. We hope to attract a good number of cornetts, sackbuts, violins and other
strings, continuo and singers.
The previous Sunday there will be another in our series of Burnham baroque chamber
music days, this time organised by Peter Collier in conjunction with Friends of the
Baroque Week. Peter has an enormous library of music so you can always expect to
discover something new.
Waltham Abbey has a wedding on 10th May so EEMF have booked St Sepulchre’s in
Holborn Viaduct for Philip Thorby’s workshop on the Padovano mass. I hope we’ll get
back to Waltham Abbey next year when it will be TVEMF’s turn to run this joint event.
Padovano was organist at St Mark’s before moving to the Hapsburg court in Graz so
we can anticipate another magnificent polychoral work.
Irene Auerbach was lamenting the cutbacks to the Early Music Show in the November
Tamesis, but while I was browsing through the BBC I-Player radio over the holidays I
discovered that there are 123 editions available as podcasts. That should keep up us
all going for some time, and in addition there are several hundred editions of
Composer of the Week, including many earlier composers.
It looks as if I shall be continuing as Chairman for a while, but cutting back on some
of my hands-on involvement with TVEMF events. It would be good if we could find
some volunteers to help with catering at workshops and perhaps even have custody of
the urn and cup-holders, at least some of the time.
I'm currently attempting to allocate groups for the Renaissance day. I suppose that
my instincts as a scientist and computer programmer make me yearn to find the
perfect solution, preferably using a computer program and minimal effort. Experience
suggests however that there will always be intractable problems to which no perfect
solution is possible, and this is clearly one of them. Fortunately people are pretty
tolerant and also flexible enough to find solutions I hadn't even considered.
The Georgian workshop is proving to be popular, though I believe more people can be
accommodated. I'm hoping that nobody turns up expecting music from Georgian
England or indeed from Georgia USA. Please note that the closing date was wrong on
the form and you can book until February 8th.
Don’t forget that subscriptions became due on the first of January. The new rates
are: standard £9.00, family (any number of people at the same address, receiving
only one Tamesis) £12.00 and full-time students £5.00. If you are paying by standing
order and failed to change the amount then you owe £2 which can be paid by cheque,
bank transfer (bank account number 00691902 sort code 30-94-28) or in cash at an
event. Those who have not paid as of the 8th of January will see a £ sign at the top
right of their address label. You can download a standing order form from the web
Letters to the Editor
I notice a query about the identity of one Theophilus, in the review by Sidney Ross
His legend was popular in the middle ages, and he was saved by the Virgin, hence his
appearance in Mouton's Ave Maria.
There are numerous Miracles of the Virgin floating around medieval literature; this
particular one appears as a c13 play in Old French (and elsewhere, including
The story is related to the Faust legend, and probably predates it: the protagonist
sells his soul to the Devil. This chap was sacked by his bishop and made a pact with
the Devil in disgust. He duly gets his job and honours back but then, conscience-
stricken, prays to Mary to save him ... which she does, by revoking the pact.
Bounty at Burnham
A pleasant autumn day, sunshine and a day to participate in music making at
Burnham organised by Vicky. Coffee and biscuits to start with and then we were
ready to start playing.
My first group played music by Telemann and Boismortier for three flutes and
continuo, an interesting combination. I know that Boismortier wrote some lovely
music for my own instrument the gamba, loads of it thankfully, but I never knew he
could write so beautifully for flutes, and in the hands of three gifted flutes this was an
excellent start to my day.
The second session of the day our group, two recorders, treble viol and continuo,
tackled music by Muffat, a composer I have never played before. These are suites
written for a small band, airs, gavottes, gigues and so on, but really quite charming
Lunch time came and I went to Burnham village to buy a sandwich for lunch, but the
amount of shops that were closed and shut I found a bit sad. Burnham is a very
pretty village and deserves better, but I suppose this recession has hit all parts of our
country badly. Things will get better I’m sure.
After lunch my next group started off with our great friend, Telemann, a piece for two
flutes, violin, viola and continuo. My part had quite a few semiquavers, the first of the
day, that crossed four strings and brought me out in a bit of a sweat. Can anyone tell
me why composers always put semiquavers in fast movements?
The real find of the day for me was a piece for the same line-up by W F Bach. This
was really superior music, profound, meaningful and in quite a different class to the
much lighter music I’d been playing previously, a real gem.
Then tea break, cake and biscuits. I could say my last session went off with a bang,
real fireworks! We played two concertos by Albinoni and Vivaldi for two oboes, two
violins and continuo. TVEMF’s finest, Judy and Clare, played the oboe parts and two
guys played the violins, a real roller-coaster ride I felt, brilliant!
The day went too quickly and then it was time to go home. I would thank Vicky and
her jolly band of helpers for making this day such a success. See you all in January!
The weather was foul in 1571/72, the year Michael Praetorius was born. Europe’s
descent into the Little Ice Age was bringing storms and floods in its wake; the
agricultural economy suffered, peasants starved and pundits murmured about
Now fast-forward more than 400 years, to December 8th, 2013. The tables of
Amersham’s Community Centre groan with food, and most of us have adjusted our
views on the meteorological powers of witches, but history had not finished with us. A
storm surge, the worst in 60 years, had hit the East coast the previous week, and
disrupted the preparation of the day’s repertoire. It is a testament to the
resourcefulness of conductor Philip Thorby, a Suffolk resident, that we had scores to
play from; and it was with some relief that we set about celebrating Advent in style.
Seventeenth century Saxony was untroubled by the EU Working Time Directive, and
Praetorius’s output was prodigious. His collected compositions over the 50 years of
his life - not to speak of his writings about instruments and performance practice - run
to 21 volumes. So the three pieces we sang and played on the day did no more than
dip a toe into his work. We started with two of his settings of standards of the period:
two choirs echoed one another in the Lutheran chorale Wachet auf, ruft uns die
Stimme, then the rafters rang to the exuberant 7-part Christmas hymn Singt, Ihr
lieben Christen all. The tune, Resonet in Laudibus, goes back at least to the 14C, its
rocking rhythm familiar as the cradle song Joseph lieber, Joseph mein.
The ratio of instrumentalists to singers
was higher than average for these
events, and if you screened out the
reindeer jumpers and snowman
earrings it was possible to imagine
that Praetorius, whose woodcuts of
supplement his textbook Syntagma
Musicum, might have recognised the
scene - we had all sizes and shapes in
wood and metal, from the double bass
to the sopranino recorder, through all
those evocative renaissance names:
curtals, viols, sackbuts, theorbo, cornetts.
and you could tell we were having a
good time, because we didn’t know
when to stop. how we struggled with
rests - surely the most inappropriately
named compositional components - as
one interloper after another crashed
the silence. Praetorius himself
waspishly notes in Syntagma Musicum
that ‘the primary faults of cantors
and singers are that they do not enunciate the text clearly and dislike counting rests’,
but was kind enough to note that sometimes it was not ‘forgetfulness or error’ but
because ‘a performer … is studiously listening to and enjoying the other parts’.
Given a bit of practice, though, we eventually blended into a reasonably harmonious
sound, and surprised ourselves with the improvement. Philip was even able
occasionally to stop conducting and let us romp our own way through the pages - he
looked surprised too.
Lunch at the Christmas workshop is always a Jacob’s join, and living proof that
participants can make food as well as music. No ice age famine for us latter-day
Lutheran burghers as we munched salads and sausages and pasties, and sank wine
and chocolate cake and lemon meringue.
The logical followup to such indulgence is digestive contemplation, but though we next
moved metaphorically to Spain, it wasn’t for a siesta but to the Catalan composer
He was born in 1618, a generation later than Michael Praetorius. He spent his
working life as choirmaster in the mountaintop monastery of Monserrat, but his
cloistered existence did not mean isolation from the cultural currents swirling through
Iberia at the time. Spain had grown rich on treasure from its Central and South
American colonies, and alongside goods imported from the New World came fresh
ideas and possibilities in all kinds of subjects including music. Composers were
influenced by the Church’s attempts to connect more closely with the everyday lives
of the faithful, and began to give secular songs devotional lyrics and incorporate them
into services, especially around Christmas.
Thus Cererols, like Praetorius before him, used arrangements of popular songs in a
religious setting and in vernacular languages. His villancico Serafín que con Dulce
Harmonía, which we tackled next, is based on the tune of Marizápalos, probably
another import from Latin America. Villancicos have a verse and refrain structure,
and again the setting was for two choirs, with a small group of slightly bashful
volunteers singing the verses.
Finally, as the winter dusk fell we returned to Michael Praetorius. By the time his
volume of chorale concertos, Polyhymnia Caduceatrix et Panegyrica, appeared in
1619, Praetorius had discovered the new music coming out of Venice. To his regret
he never travelled to Italy, but these late compositions show what he could do in the
Italian style. He invests sober Lutheran chorales with a lavish sumptuousness
through multiple choirs, instrumental sinfonias and a for the first time, a basso
His setting of Nun komm, der Heiden Heiland uses three choirs, interleaved with
instrumental sections. Our small group of players spiritedly took on the rapid passage
work that twinkled between blocks of choral ritornelli, to heartfelt applause from
The richness and complexity of this music illustrated for us the distance Lutheran
choral music had travelled in Praetorius’s hands. With our twenty first century
hindsight, we also seemed to hear echoes of the day when, a century after
Praetorius’s birth and only 12km south of his birthplace, in the small town of Eisenach
another baby would be born, and named Johann Sebastian, and would take the
Lutheran choral tradition to its apotheosis.
I Fagiolini Gesualdo workshop
Described to us as a workshop for “looking at the music of Gesualdo”, the event on
November 17th at Waltham Abbey for the Friends of I Fagiolini and others was an
intense study of just four difficult madrigals from Gesualdo’s the 5th and 6th books.
They were Asciugate I belli Occhi, Merce grido Piangendo, S’io non moro and Mille
volte il di moro.
Robert Hollingworth, I Fagiolini’s indefatigable leader, gives a useful introduction to
Gesualdo: “ It's time to lay to rest to the lazy ‘truth’ that Gesualdo killed his wife, then
lamented this in tortured music. Murdering your wife as a punishment for adultery
was acceptable behaviour in 16th-century Italy and Gesualdo’s music focusses less on
guilt and more on betrayal. Rather, the avant-garde nature of his music developed
from a prolonged stay at the home of Italy’s hothouse of musical modernism, the
court of Ferrara. In that highly experimental ethos, and surrounded by a brilliant
vocal ensemble, Gesualdo took the late madrigal to undreamt-of extremes. His final
works sound closer to Brahms or even Wagner, though in the dying embers of the
Renaissance; what he meant by this has been misunderstood.”
Weeks in advance of the one-day workshop the 24 participants had received complete
preparation materials. We were provided with access to:
the full printed scores in those beautiful I Fagiolini editions
recordings of the Italian texts for pronunciation
rehearsal sound files of the complete madrigal and
rehearsal sound files of each separate part made prominent while the other four
continued in the background
But it was evident that only some of the 24 or so singers had taken advantage of all
these resources and actually worked on these difficult pieces in advance, since a lot of
time was needed to get the notes in place, and the pronunciation the way Robert
wanted it. That said, we were treated to much fine detail of musical and linguistic
theory and practice, including the effect of individual vowels on the way a chord is
tuned and actually sounds. A workshop with Robert Hollingworth is a lot more than
singing and getting it right. It is a complete and fascinating lecture on all these
aspects, as well as the history, background, and subsequent research into
interpretation and performance. In this we were well-served, although there were
some who would have liked to have sung more and listened a little less.
A week later, those of us in the London area could have gone to hear I Fagiolini
themselves singing two of the ones we worked on at Islington’s Union Chapel. I find
there is nothing quite as satisfying as hearing the experts singing something I know
really well, and this opportunity to hear it a week later, before I had forgotten it (Why
do I forget one-day workshop pieces so quickly?) was a treat indeed.
In this reviewer’s opinion, the principle of supplying study and rehearsal resources in
advance of a singing workshop is an excellent principle, one that more of them should
adopt, even if the extra work means higher cost for the singers.
Seminars in Medieval and Renaissance Music
There are regular seminars in the Wharton Room of All Souls College Oxford on
Thursdays from 5 to 7pm during term time. The speaker’s presentation is followed by
an hour of discussion during which wine is served. I was particularly interested to
note Davitt Moroney’s contribution on 27th February next year on reconstructing
Stefano Rossetto’s 50-part motet Consolamini, consolamini popule meus, surely a
candidate for a Waltham Abbey workshop. Seminars are listed on the university’s
Faculty of Music web site www.music.ox.ac.uk.
Stephen Willis musical celebration
My stepfather Stephen Willis, who sadly passed away in September, was a passionate
musician, in many guises. He sang countertenor, conducted choirs (my first memory
of him is as choirmaster of the church in Cowden, Kent, where I sang aged 9 or so),
played recorder, viol, hurdy-gurdy, and various loud wind instruments including the
I am organising a musical celebration of his life, which will take place on the afternoon
of Sunday 27 April 2014, at St James’s Church, Hampton Hill – just outside London. I
hope many of his musical friends and colleagues will come, and contribute too. We
will provide tea afterwards in the church hall.
Please contact me if you would like to come, and if you would like to take part in the
Jill Davies (Jill Lockhart)
Opportunities to Make Music
Morley College is putting on an Early Music Performance Project running on three
consecutive Sundays beginning on the 26th January, directed by Ibi Aziz.
The ensemble will comprise of a core of good standard period string players, with
other instruments (winds, plucked continuo, keyboards, and perhaps even brass) built
around it. Singers can also join.
Each Sunday will start at 11am and end at 5pm, with a lunch break in the middle and
possibly a short tea break. On the final Sunday, there is planned to be a performance
at 4 pm. For details contact ibiazizgmail.com (07939 343 078) or see
* * *
TVEMF member Norma Herdson is holding another in her series of Baroque Workshops
on Sunday, March 23 at Bourne End, near Maidenhead. There will be no singers this
time so that conductor Michael Sanderson can spend time on technique. Playing is at
415 pitch, mostly with gut strings and baroque bows but players of modern strings
will be welcome provided that they are willing to retune their instruments (one
semitone lower). Repertoire will include Water Music by Handel and Telemann. More
information from nherdsonbtinternet.com.
Thurs 6, 6.30-7.30pm. A Forgotten Rivalry: Sonatas for Viol and Cello. The viola da gamba
was mainly used as a solo instrument in the 18th century until it was supplanted by the cello.
This programme explores the relationship between the two instruments and includes virtuoso
sonatas that highlight the nature of each. Ibrahim Aziz (viola da gamba), Poppy Walshaw
(baroque cello) & Katie de La Matter (hpschd).
Tues 11, 6.30-7.30pm. Music by CPE Bach
Rondos, fantasias and sonatas from CPE Bach’s extraordinary output demonstrate why, in his
lifetime, he enjoyed greater celebrity than his Cantor father. An unusual opportunity to hear
these works on both harpsichord and clavichord in the ideal setting of Handel House. The
concert is performed by Carole Cerasi.
Thurs 13, 6.30-7.30pm. Handel and his Rivals
Handel spent four cut-throat years from 1733-1737 fighting to secure dominance over his rival
company ‘Opera of the Nobility’. Music & stories will be presented that will illuminate Handel,
his work & competitors during this time. The Ballo Baroque Ensemble - Randall Scotting
(countertenor) and Marie Van Rhijn (harpsichord).
Thurs 20, 6.30-7.30pm. L’Entretien des Dieux
Canadian harpsichordist Martin Robidoux will perform French repertoire from the 17th century
by composers Chambonnière, d’Anglebert and Couperin.
Sat 22, 2-4pm. British Harpsichord Society Weekend Recital: Handel’s Duellist Johann
Mattheson. Though good friends, rivalry in the opera pit caused Mattheson and Handel to fight
a duel. Luckily neither came to any harm. Gilbert Rowland leads an afternoon of music by
Mattheson with Masumi Yamamoto and other players.
Sun 23, 12-6pm (last admission 5.30pm) Handel’s Birthday. Handel House opens its doors on
Handel’s 329th birthday. Join us on this special day free of charge to visit his home, view our
latest exhibition and listen to music performed throughout the day.
Thurs 27, 6.30-7.30pm. The Art of the Viola
Despite not visiting England, the Italian violinist and composer Corelli’s influence was felt in
London & inspired Handel and other composer’s works. The French composer Michel Corrette
did visit London in the 1770s and until recently his works for viola were little known. Elena
Artamonova (viola) & Kamilla Isanbaeva (hpschd) perform works by these composers.
Sat1, 2-3.30pm. Exhibition Study Session: She who penetrated the heart
‘Handel was very fond of Mrs. Cibber’ wrote Burney. Handel first saw her perform when she
was eighteen and he forty-seven, and seems to have been permanently captivated.
Notoriously irascible with other singers, he patiently coached Susannah from the harpsichord,
playing each phrase for her to memorise. Following her agonizing adultery trial, he gave to her
the most suffering moment in Messiah; later he immortalized their friendship in Samson. It
might be said that she who ‘penetrated the heart’ with her expressive performance, became
the muse for Handelian Oratorio. The day will be led by [TVEMF member] Helen Dymond, a
lecturer at the City Literary Institute and an established authority on Handel’s life and work.
Thurs 6, 6.30-7.30pm. Music of London-Town
At the turn of the 18th century, London was evolving into a thriving musical metropolis.
Recorder quartet Consort Audite Nova explore works by the city’s own composers and music
by those who moved to live and work here.
Sat 8, 2-3.30pm. ‘Tweedledum and Tweedledee agreed to have a battle...’ So wrote poet John
Byrom of the rivalry between Handel and Bononcini. Although Handel enjoyed greater
popularity, Bononcini eventually fled London after being charged with plagiarism. Emily
Atkinson (soprano), Cathy Bell (mezzo), Nikolay Ginov (baroque cello) and Asako Ogawa
(hpschd) present these two masters’ vocal works alongside music by their contemporaries.
Tues 11, 6.30-7.30pm. British Harpsichord Society Recital: Virtuosic Encounters
Harpsichordist Rachel Factor presents works by baroque composers known for their
competition & rivalry with others - JS Bach, Marchand, Couperin, Handel and Scarlatti.
Thurs 13, 6.30-7.30pm. Duality
Celebrating the multi-faceted virtuosic repertoire for violin & harpsichord, Jane Gordon (violin)
and Julian Perkins (harpsichord) explore music ranging from the flamboyant virtuosity in
Corelli’s sonata to the ruminate brilliance inherent in Bach’s music.
Thurs 20, 6.30-7.30pm. The Never-Ending Buzz. Musical life in London was vibrant in the 18th
century as it is now. Styles and creativity met in a never-ending buzz. This programme
includes music by Handel & his contemporaries - both colleagues & enemies. Les Nations
Réunies - Ruth Bruckner (recorder), Yu-Wei Hu (traverso), Kunihiro Mimura (ogamba), Johan
Löfving (theorbo) & Marie van Rhijn (harpsichord).
Thurs 27, 6.30-7.30pm. Masters of the French Baroque
Musica Poetica London present works by three of the greatest French composers of the
baroque period: Leclair, Marais and Rameau. Characterised by sensuous melodies and intricate
unusual harmonies these pieces show how they are both dramatic and strikingly original.
Claudia Norz (violin), Kate Conway (viola da gamba) and Oliver-John Ruthven (harpsichord).
EXHIBITION AND DISPLAYS
THE TRIUMPH OF TIME OVER MUSIC: GEORGE FRIDERIC HANDEL AND CHARLES
CLAY’S MUSICAL CLOCKS (20 November 2013 –23 February 2014)
In the 1730s Handel provided music for a series of clocks created by watch and clockmaker
Charles Clay. These beautiful machines, which incorporated automata, paintings, sculptures,
furniture and gold and silver work by some of the finest artisans in London, also included
chimes and pump organs that played extended musical excerpts from popular operas and
This exhibition provides the opportunity to view a Clay clock from the Birmingham Museum
and Art Gallery in an intimate Georgian setting which recalls the context in which such new
inventions were originally viewed in the clockmaker’s own home. It will be joined by a gilt
bronze relief from another Clay clock on loan from the V&A, and a manuscript of Handel’s clock
tunes from the British Library.
In addition a recording of the music from a Clay clock in a private collection demonstrates the
earliest ‘recordings’ of Handel’s music made during his lifetime.
On display at Handel House is a magnificent marble bust of George Frideric Handel, on loan
from the Royal Collection. Attributed to French sculptor Louis-François Roubiliac (1702-1762),
the bust has been in possession of the Royal Family since its creation.
SHE WAS DESPISED: HANDEL AND SUSANNAH CIBBER
Wednesday 26 February – Sunday 28 September 2014
To celebrate the tercentenary of her birth, Handel House Museum presents an exhibition on
the life and work of Susannah Cibber.
From a promising start as a singer in a small opera company, Cibber’s career and social
standing were fatally blighted by the scandalous trial in which her husband Theophilus accused
her of adultery. Unable to appear on the London stage, she fled to Dublin. It was here that she
was chosen by Handel to sing in the first performance of Messiah in 1742, giving a moving
performance of the aria ‘He was despiséd’.
From her performance in the London premiere of Messiah a year later her career blossomed
once again. She became one of the most significant actresses of the 18th century, and for
many years was David Garrick’s leading lady.
The exhibition will tell Susannah’s fascinating, dramatic and moving life story, through
exhibits, contemporary texts, music and a programme of related events.
On Saturday afternoons at 3pm you can join a short talk researched and delivered by our
knowledgeable volunteers on a variety of subjects including costumes, paintings, music and
London in the 18th century. Talks are included in the museum admission price. Exhibition
talks will last between 15-20 minutes and will take place on Saturday 29 March and Saturday